Jamie
This rating system will mostly likely pertain to those within the alliance that are interested in commercial promotion and marketing their lures. It will garner participating members some measure of clout, in regards to offering the public a bait of quality. In addition, if the alliance does grow to significant size all members will reap from this. Not all members will be driven to sell their wares, which is evident by the diversity here on TU. Some labor for the satisfaction of creating their own bait and fishing the bait. Others are interested in the commercial promotion and marketing. From the hobbyist to the professional we all share the same interest. Don't let this idea of a rating system discourage you from actively participating in this fledgling alliance.
Texasbass,
Get over to Nathan's forum and contribute, I am confident you have something to offer.