I don't know if your repainting instructions included different eyes, but, if not, you can look for a hole punch at a craft store the same diameter you can punch out discs of blue painter's tape, and just mask the eyes, instead of removing them.
I do that with a 5/16" punch I inherited from one of my kids' school projects, and, if the disc is too big, I use a sharp exacto knife to trace the smaller eye out, using the outside lure eye groove as a guide.
Did I mention I was lazy, too? Hahaha