fatfingers,
There is no possible way to scientifically confirm either argument at this point. In hindsight, our water systems are probably like comparing apples and oranges. .
Our MNR has stopped stocking muskies back in the 90's unlike your waters that are actively being stocked by your MNR. So, your waters hold more muskies and are therefore they're easier to catch.
We are left chasing natural reproductive muskies which are more difficult to locate and catch. I think we'll leave it at, we'll agree to disagree LoL!
Respectfully,
s54