Alright, I gave it a shot, but never was successful. Here is my list of how the polyurethane resin reacted to the plaster. Unsealad plaster:Poly adhered. Plaster sealed with Elmers: Poly adhered. Wet unsealed plaster: Poly removed easily but it had a bubbly surface. Unsealed plaster with vaseline: Bubbly poly surface. Sealed plaster with vaseline: Bubbly poly surface. Sealed plaster with pam: Bubbly poly surface. Plaster sealed with paint: Closest to success, but the paint came off on the poly. I ended up just doing what vodkaman said first and made a silicone mold. I am sure there is a way to do this successfully in plaster, but it definitely involves sealing the plaster so no bubbles get into the poly. Thanks all for the help.