well first off, trial and error is a huge part of what makes this so much fun & rewarding.
im not sure what the huddleston feels like, most of the plastic you will find is going to be within the same range. most plastic retailers offer a soft, medium, and hard mix. medium is going to be the most popular and will feel like most of the plastics you'll find out there from strike king, yum, zoom, ri.
if the huddleston is softer than your normal baits, get a mix of soft plastic but also buy some softener on top of that. if its harder, get hard with hardener. but i'm guessing medium would do the trick.
research on these forums and experimenting yourself is going to give you a journey that is worth as much as the destination if you ask me. a lot of people on here have good ways of doing it, but to be honest there are always new and better ways, find what suits you the best.