Too much softner?

[Jig Man]

I use Calhoun’s medium and have not needed to use my softener in a long time.  I’m wanting to make extremely soft slick shiners.  How much softener would be the max in 4 oz of plastisol?

[Tiderunner]

I use MF medium a lot and to soften up my baits I might use 1 teaspoon to 4oz

Only an estimate of course as I don’t measure out that amount. 
To make a bait extra soft start with 2 or 3 teaspoons and go from there.

Your idea of super soft may be different than mine . 
You will more than likely have to experiment with the softener until you get what you want.  
When I make stick baits I’ll use MF sinking soft add my salt or glass beads and then use softener there too. Typically about the same as what I use in medium, and even then I may have to adjust the amounts.

Start with plain plastic. Add a teaspoon of not what you want. Carefully reheat and add another teaspoon. Still not what you want?

Repeat as necessary.  Might take a few tries but once you get your desired softness write your recipe down 

[Jig Man]

Thanks.  I write down everything in a spiral notebook.  I didn’t remember if could be added to reheats or not.

[Tiderunner]

3 hours ago, Jig Man said:

Thanks.  I write down everything in a spiral notebook.  I didn’t remember if could be added to reheats or not.

I do reheats with softener all the time. Hardener is less forgiving